U.S. loses WTO case again PDF Print E-mail
Written by Stumo   
Tuesday, 03 June 2008

The U.S. lost a cotton subsidy case in the WTO.  Brazil and several West African countries brought the case. 

Brazil and several West African cotton-producing countries have long claimed that their farmers suffer because of Washington’s payments to cotton growers, which amount to some $3 billion a year.

Any trade sanctions imposed by Brazil will likely target American. trademarks, patents and commercial services, the South American country has warned. 

The WTO appeals panel was not elected by anybody.  I don't know who was on the panel.  Somebody chose them, but not us.  The proceedings are secret.

Other countries focus upon enforcing trade agreements.  The U.S. generally loses.  (Global Trade Watch has an excellent summary of U.S. performance in WTO cases).  We are a "free market country" but we lose cases all the time.  Our U.S. Trade Representative focuses upon getting new trade agreements as fast as we can.  Never mind enforcement.  We don't enforce the rules. 

But it was an unlawful subsidy.  Subsidies are bad.  Bad things.  $3 billion.  How can you be pro-subsidy?

 

How did the OPEC countries develop their oil?  Government ownership.  How did China develop its economy?  Government subsidies and direct ownership  of a massive percentage of the economy.  How did the U.S. and every developed country in the world develop?  By making an economic plan and nursing key industries deemed good for the people.

Currency manipulation is the biggest subsidy there is.  But our government does nothing.  You are a protectionist if you want to curtail currency manipulation.  Somebody might retaliate if we enforce the rules.

U.S. trade policy is a farce.  It means getting another trade agreement, no matter what it says.  It is a distraction from the problems of the day.  Sapping energy from worthy endeavors.  A full rethink is needed.  Let's take a pause from new deals.

Trackback(0)
Comments (0)add
Write comment

busy
 
< Prev   Next >