Squanderville versus Thriftville PDF Print E-mail
Written by Stumo   
Wednesday, 12 March 2008

Warren Buffett's excellent 2003 article in Fortune, Squanderville versus Thriftville, is classic.  I had some trouble finding it before, so am enshrining it here, below the fold.  Wouldn't it be great if someone actually acted on the piece 5 years ago?  We'd have some countermeasures in place and be headed in a different economic direction.

****


Squanderville versus Thriftville

By Warren Buffet

Oct 2003 FORTUNE

I'm about to deliver a warning regarding the U.S. trade deficit and also suggest a remedy for the problem. But first I need to mention two reasons you might want to be skeptical about what I say. To begin, my forecasting record with respect to macroeconomics is far from inspiring. For example, over the past two decades I was excessively fearful of inflation. More to the point at hand, I started way back in 1987 to publicly worry about our mounting trade deficits -- and, as you know, we've not only survived but also thrived. So on the trade front, score at least one "wolf" for me. Nevertheless, I am crying wolf again and this time backing it with Berkshire Hathaway's money. Through the spring of 2002, I had lived nearly 72 years without purchasing a foreign currency. Since then Berkshire has made significant investments in -- and today holds -- several currencies. I won't give you particulars; in fact, it is largely irrelevant which currencies they are. What does matter is the underlying point: To hold other currencies is to believe that the dollar will decline.

Both as an American and as an investor, I actually hope these commitments prove to be a mistake. Any profits Berkshire might make from currency trading would pale against the losses the company and our shareholders, in other aspects of their lives, would incur from a plunging dollar.

But as head of Berkshire Hathaway, I am in charge of investing its money in ways that make sense. And my reason for finally putting my money where my mouth has been so long is that our trade deficit has greatly worsened, to the point that our country's "net worth," so to speak, is now being transferred abroad at an alarming rate.

A perpetuation of this transfer will lead to major trouble. To understand why, take a wildly fanciful trip with me to two isolated, side-by-side islands of equal size, Squanderville and Thriftville. Land is the only capital asset on these islands, and their communities are primitive, needing only food and producing only food. Working eight hours a day, in fact, each inhabitant can produce enough food to sustain himself or herself. And for a long time that's how things go along. On each island everybody works the prescribed eight hours a day, which means that each society is self-sufficient.

Eventually, though, the industrious citizens of Thriftville decide to do some serious saving and investing, and they start to work 16 hours a day. In this mode they continue to live off the food they produce in eight hours of work but begin exporting an equal amount to their one and only trading outlet, Squanderville.

The citizens of Squanderville are ecstatic about this turn of events, since they can now live their lives free from toil but eat as well as ever. Oh, yes, there's a quid pro quo -- but to the Squanders, it seems harmless: All that the Thrifts want in exchange for their food is Squanderbonds (which are denominated, naturally, in Squanderbucks).

Over time Thriftville accumulates an enormous amount of these bonds, which at their core represent claim checks on the future output of Squanderville. A few pundits in Squanderville smell trouble coming. They foresee that for the Squanders both to eat and to pay off -- or simply service -- the debt they're piling up will eventually require them to work more than eight hours a day. But the residents of Squanderville are in no mood to listen to such doomsaying.

Meanwhile, the citizens of Thriftville begin to get nervous. Just how good, they ask, are the IOUs of a shiftless island? So the Thrifts change strategy: Though they continue to hold some bonds, they sell most of them to Squanderville residents for Squanderbucks and use the proceeds to buy Squanderville land. And eventually the Thrifts own all of Squanderville.

At that point, the Squanders are forced to deal with an ugly equation: They must now not only return to working eight hours a day in order to eat -- they have nothing left to trade -- but must also work additional hours to service their debt and pay Thriftville rent on the land so imprudently sold. In effect, Squanderville has been colonized by purchase rather than conquest.

It can be argued, of course, that the present value of the future production that Squanderville must forever ship to Thriftville only equates to the production Thriftville initially gave up and that therefore both have received a fair deal. But since one generation of Squanders gets the free ride and future generations pay in perpetuity for it, there are -- in economist talk -- some pretty dramatic "intergenerational inequities."

Let's think of it in terms of a family: Imagine that I, Warren Buffett, can get the suppliers of all that I consume in my lifetime to take Buffett family IOUs that are payable, in goods and services and with interest added, by my descendants. This scenario may be viewed as effecting an even trade between the Buffett family unit and its creditors. But the generations of Buffetts following me are not likely to applaud the deal (and, heaven forbid, may even attempt to welsh on it).

Think again about those islands: Sooner or later the Squanderville government, facing ever greater payments to service debt, would decide to embrace highly inflationary policies -- that is, issue more Squanderbucks to dilute the value of each. After all, the government would reason, those irritating Squanderbonds are simply claims on specific numbers of Squanderbucks, not on bucks of specific value. In short, making Squanderbucks less valuable would ease the island's fiscal pain.

That prospect is why I, were I a resident of Thriftville, would opt for direct ownership of Squanderville land rather than bonds of the island's government. Most governments find it much harder morally to seize foreign-owned property than they do to dilute the purchasing power of claim checks foreigners hold. Theft by stealth is preferred to theft by force.

So what does all this island hopping have to do with the U.S.? Simply put, after World War II and up until the early 1970s we operated in the industrious Thriftville style, regularly selling more abroad than we purchased. We concurrently invested our surplus abroad, with the result that our net investment -- that is, our holdings of foreign assets less foreign holdings of U.S. assets -- increased (under methodology, since revised, that the government was then using) from $37 billion in 1950 to $68 billion in 1970. In those days, to sum up, our country's "net worth," viewed in totality, consisted of all the wealth within our borders plus a modest portion of the wealth in the rest of the world.

Additionally, because the U.S. was in a net ownership position with respect to the rest of the world, we realized net investment income that, piled on top of our trade surplus, became a second source of investable funds. Our fiscal situation was thus similar to that of an individual who was both saving some of his salary and reinvesting the dividends from his existing nest egg.

In the late 1970s the trade situation reversed, producing deficits that initially ran about 1 percent of GDP. That was hardly serious, particularly because net investment income remained positive. Indeed, with the power of compound interest working for us, our net ownership balance hit its high in 1980 at $360 billion.

Since then, however, it's been all downhill, with the pace of decline rapidly accelerating in the past five years. Our annual trade deficit now exceeds 4 percent of GDP. Equally ominous, the rest of the world owns a staggering $2.5 trillion more of the U.S. than we own of other countries. Some of this $2.5 trillion is invested in claim checks -- U.S. bonds, both governmental and private -- and some in such assets as property and equity securities.

In effect, our country has been behaving like an extraordinarily rich family that possesses an immense farm. In order to consume 4 percent more than we produce -- that's the trade deficit -- we have, day by day, been both selling pieces of the farm and increasing the mortgage on what we still own.

To put the $2.5 trillion of net foreign ownership in perspective, contrast it with the $12 trillion value of publicly owned U.S. stocks or the equal amount of U.S. residential real estate or what I would estimate as a grand total of $50 trillion in national wealth. Those comparisons show that what's already been transferred abroad is meaningful -- in the area, for example, of 5 percent of our national wealth.

More important, however, is that foreign ownership of our assets will grow at about $500 billion per year at the present trade-deficit level, which means that the deficit will be adding about one percentage point annually to foreigners' net ownership of our national wealth. As that ownership grows, so will the annual net investment income flowing out of this country. That will leave us paying ever-increasing dividends and interest to the world rather than being a net receiver of them, as in the past. We have entered the world of negative compounding -- goodbye pleasure, hello pain.

We were taught in Economics 101 that countries could not for long sustain large, ever-growing trade deficits. At a point, so it was claimed, the spree of the consumption-happy nation would be braked by currency-rate adjustments and by the unwillingness of creditor countries to accept an endless flow of IOUs from the big spenders. And that's the way it has indeed worked for the rest of the world, as we can see by the abrupt shutoffs of credit that many profligate nations have suffered in recent decades.

The U.S., however, enjoys special status. In effect, we can behave today as we wish because our past financial behavior was so exemplary -- and because we are so rich. Neither our capacity nor our intention to pay is questioned, and we continue to have a mountain of desirable assets to trade for consumables. In other words, our national credit card allows us to charge truly breathtaking amounts. But that card's credit line is not limitless.

The time to halt this trading of assets for consumables is now, and I have a plan to suggest for getting it done. My remedy may sound gimmicky, and in truth it is a tariff called by another name. But this is a tariff that retains most free-market virtues, neither protecting specific industries nor punishing specific countries nor encouraging trade wars. This plan would increase our exports and might well lead to increased overall world trade. And it would balance our books without there being a significant decline in the value of the dollar, which I believe is otherwise almost certain to occur.

We would achieve this balance by issuing what I will call Import Certificates (ICs) to all U.S. exporters in an amount equal to the dollar value of their exports. Each exporter would, in turn, sell the ICs to parties -- either exporters abroad or importers here -- wanting to get goods into the U.S. To import $1 million of goods, for example, an importer would need ICs that were the byproduct of $1 million of exports. The inevitable result: trade balance.

Because our exports total about $80 billion a month, ICs would be issued in huge, equivalent quantities -- that is, 80 billion certificates a month -- and would surely trade in an exceptionally liquid market. Competition would then determine who among those parties wanting to sell to us would buy the certificates and how much they would pay. (I visualize that the certificates would be issued with a short life, possibly of six months, so that speculators would be discouraged from accumulating them.)

For illustrative purposes, let's postulate that each IC would sell for 10 cents -- that is, 10 cents per dollar of exports behind them. Other things being equal, this amount would mean a U.S. producer could realize 10 percent more by selling his goods in the export market than by selling them domestically, with the extra 10 percent coming from his sales of ICs.

In my opinion, many exporters would view this as a reduction in cost, one that would let them cut the prices of their products in international markets. Commodity-type products would particularly encourage this kind of behavior. If aluminum, for example, was selling for 66 cents per pound domestically and ICs were worth 10 percent, domestic aluminum producers could sell for about 60 cents per pound (plus transportation costs) in foreign markets and still earn normal margins. In this scenario, the output of the U.S. would become significantly more competitive and exports would expand. Along the way, the number of jobs would grow.

Foreigners selling to us, of course, would face tougher economics. But that's a problem they're up against no matter what trade "solution" is adopted -- and make no mistake, a solution must come. (As Herb Stein said, "If something cannot go on forever, it will stop.") In one way the IC approach would give countries selling to us great flexibility, since the plan does not penalize any specific industry or product. In the end, the free market would determine what would be sold in the U.S. and who would sell it. The ICs would determine only the aggregate dollar volume of what was sold.

To see what would happen to imports, let's look at a car now entering the U.S. at a cost to the importer of $20,000. Under the new plan and the assumption that ICs sell for 10 percent, the importer's cost would rise to $22,000. If demand for the car was exceptionally strong, the importer might manage to pass all of this on to the American consumer. In the usual case, however, competitive forces would take hold, requiring the foreign manufacturer to absorb some, if not all, of the $2,000 IC cost.

There is no free lunch in the IC plan: It would have certain serious negative consequences for U.S. citizens. Prices of most imported products would increase, and so would the prices of certain competitive products manufactured domestically. The cost of the ICs, either in whole or in part, would therefore typically act as a tax on consumers.

That is a serious drawback. But there would be drawbacks also to the dollar continuing to lose value or to our increasing tariffs on specific products or instituting quotas on them -- courses of action that in my opinion offer a smaller chance of success. Above all, the pain of higher prices on goods imported today dims beside the pain we will eventually suffer if we drift along and trade away ever larger portions of our country's net worth.

I believe that ICs would produce, rather promptly, a U.S. trade equilibrium well above present export levels but below present import levels. The certificates would moderately aid all our industries in world competition, even as the free market determined which of them ultimately met the test of "comparative advantage."

This plan would not be copied by nations that are net exporters, because their ICs would be valueless. Would major exporting countries retaliate in other ways? Would this start another Smoot-Hawley tariff war? Hardly. At the time of Smoot-Hawley we ran an unreasonable trade surplus that we wished to maintain. We now run a damaging deficit that the whole world knows we must correct.

For decades the world has struggled with a shifting maze of punitive tariffs, export subsidies, quotas, dollar-locked currencies, and the like. Many of these import-inhibiting and export-encouraging devices have long been employed by major exporting countries trying to amass ever larger surpluses -- yet significant trade wars have not erupted. Surely one will not be precipitated by a proposal that simply aims at balancing the books of the world's largest trade debtor. Major exporting countries have behaved quite rationally in the past and they will continue to do so -- though, as always, it may be in their interest to attempt to convince us that they will behave otherwise.

The likely outcome of an IC plan is that the exporting nations -- after some initial posturing -- will turn their ingenuity to encouraging imports from us. Take the position of China, which today sells us about $140 billion of goods and services annually while purchasing only $25 billion. Were ICs to exist, one course for China would be simply to fill the gap by buying 115 billion certificates annually. But it could alternatively reduce its need for ICs by cutting its exports to the U.S. or by increasing its purchases from us. This last choice would probably be the most palatable for China, and we should wish it to be so.

If our exports were to increase and the supply of ICs were therefore to be enlarged, their market price would be driven down. Indeed, if our exports expanded sufficiently, ICs would be rendered valueless and the entire plan made moot. Presented with the power to make this happen, important exporting countries might quickly eliminate the mechanisms they now use to inhibit exports from us.

Were we to install an IC plan, we might opt for some transition years in which we deliberately ran a relatively small deficit, a step that would enable the world to adjust as we gradually got where we need to be. Carrying this plan out, our government could either auction "bonus" ICs every month or simply give them, say, to less-developed countries needing to increase their exports. The latter course would deliver a form of foreign aid likely to be particularly effective and appreciated.

I will close by reminding you again that I cried wolf once before. In general, the batting average of doomsayers in the U.S. is terrible. Our country has consistently made fools of those who were skeptical about either our economic potential or our resiliency. Many pessimistic seers simply underestimated the dynamism that has allowed us to overcome problems that once seemed ominous. We still have a truly remarkable country and economy.

But I believe that in the trade deficit we also have a problem that is going to test all of our abilities to find a solution. A gently declining dollar will not provide the answer. True, it would reduce our trade deficit to a degree, but not by enough to halt the outflow of our country's net worth and the resulting growth in our investment-income deficit.

Perhaps there are other solutions that make more sense than mine. However, wishful thinking -- and its usual companion, thumb sucking -- is not among them. From what I now see, action to halt the rapid outflow of our national wealth is called for, and ICs seem the least painful and most certain way to get the job done. Just keep remembering that this is not a small problem: For example, at the rate at which the rest of the world is now making net investments in the U.S., it could annually buy and sock away nearly 4 percent of our publicly traded stocks.

In evaluating business options at Berkshire, my partner, Charles Munger, suggests that we pay close attention to his jocular wish: "All I want to know is where I'm going to die, so I'll never go there." Framers of our trade policy should heed this caution -- and steer clear of Squanderville.

FORTUNE editor at large Carol Loomis, who is a Berkshire Hathaway shareholder, worked with Warren Buffett on this article.

Trackback(1092)

1. Pamala Anderson Nude
Johan Roest Johan Roest

2. shoe size conversion
clown cupcakes clown cupcakes

3. planter warts
45 long colt ammo 45 long colt ammo

4. four seasons sunrooms
marcus schenkenberg marcus schenkenberg

5. daddys worst nightmare
camille holbrook camille holbrook

6. garnier fructis
nickelodeon hotel orlando nickelodeon hotel orlando

7. cardiolite stress test
insect fogger insect fogger

8. lexmark support
calgary health region login calgary health region login

9. madolyn smith osborne
stacy dash nude stacy dash nude

10. selfcast tv
liberator bedroom adventure gear liberator bedroom adventure gear

11. ryobi replacement parts
ford flatheads ford flatheads

12. naked black women
black dicks | the black death | black boy | black hoes | black strippers | nude black men | blacks on blonds http://www.angelfire.com/yesadult/black-dicks.html http://www.angelfire.com/yesadult/the-black-death.html http://www.angelfire.com/yesadult/big-black.html http://www.angelfire.com/yesadult/black-hoes.html http://www.angelfire.com/yesadult/black-people.html http://www.angelfire.com/yesadult/naked-black-girls.html

13. Hbukkake Snowball
Hrussan Girl Models Hrussan Girl Models

14. Hkarbon Ski Pants
Hjacklyn Zeman Nude Photos Hjacklyn Zeman Nude Photos

15. Hnude Celbrity
Hintimidating Femdom Hintimidating Femdom

16. Hakira Fubuki Uncensored
Hncis Fanfiction Tate Hncis Fanfiction Tate

17. black labs
big black dicks | black bbw | black cat | black blowjobs | big black cocks | black anal sex | black shemales http://www.angelfire.com/yesadult/big-black-dicks.html http://www.angelfire.com/yesadult/black-bbw.html http://www.angelfire.com/yesadult/black-cat.html http://www.angelfire.com/yesadult/black-gay.html http://www.angelfire.com/yesadult/big-black-cocks.html http://www.angelfire.com/yesadult/black-anal-sex.html

18. asian men
young asian | asian kung fu generation | mature asian | asian bukkake | asian cock | asian shemales | asian lesbian porn http://www.angelfire.com/adulttop/busty-asians.html http://www.angelfire.com/adulttop/asian-kung-fu-generation-0.html http://www.angelfire.com/adulttop/mature-asian.html http://www.angelfire.com/adulttop/asian-xxx.html http://www.angelfire.com/adulttop/asian-pornstars.html http://www.angelfire.com/adulttop/nude-asians.html

19. Hgabrielle Reece Naked
Htayuya Henti Htayuya Henti

20. Hadult Rubber Incontinence Pants
Hgretel Adult Costume Hgretel Adult Costume

21. Hlexiington Kentucky Strip Clubs
Happle Bottom Bootys Happle Bottom Bootys

22. Hredundant Foreskin
Hemily Vancamp Nude Hemily Vancamp Nude

23. Hhardcore Pantyfucking
Hshemale Stroker Clips Hshemale Stroker Clips

24. скачать порнофильм курск
порно фильм банзай порно фильм банзай

25. порно сайты золотого дождя
журнал детское порно журнал детское порно

26. инцес фото порно мама сын
порно фильм банзай порно фильм банзай

27. сексуальные порно девки
бесплатно смотреть видео порно бесплатно смотреть видео порно

28. порно фильмы показ
белоснежка семь гномов порно белоснежка семь гномов порно

29. chilton repair manual
orlando flordia orlando flordia

30. home cleaning tips
kevlar jeans kevlar jeans

31. remington steele fan fiction
lisa arturo nude lisa arturo nude

32. sexy celebrity pics
dr susan lark dr susan lark

33. 2009 corolla
rentre scolaire rentre scolaire

34. sample letter of reference
us defense budget consulting us defense budget consulting

35. orlando flordia
alex oloughlin alex oloughlin

36. yalta conference
versace dv once watch versace dv once watch

37. djian stories
soda can crusher soda can crusher

38. mother teresa of calcuta
anonimo watches anonimo watches

39. Randy Orton Tattoo
Spoon River Anthology Spoon River Anthology

40. Pubescent Nudes
Cheats For Clubpenguin Cheats For Clubpenguin

41. Blues Scales
Kids Chore Chart Kids Chore Chart

42. Craigs List Peoria
Rubics Cube Solution Rubics Cube Solution

43. Antelope Valley Press
Telephonie Fixe Telephonie Fixe

44. Fsu Cowgirl
Bikini Dare Wicked Weasel Bikini Dare Wicked Weasel

45. Lauren Nieuwland Nude
Binghamton Erotic Massages Binghamton Erotic Massages

46. Circumsized Penis
Non Nude Pics Non Nude Pics

47. Columbian Model Danni
Celebrity Morgue Photos Celebrity Morgue Photos

48. Coed Skinny Dipping
Free Porn Clips 89 Free Porn Clips 89

49. Vandalia Xxx
Kounin Model Kounin Model

50. Nullification Genital
Free Adult Web Cams Free Adult Web Cams

51. Penis Streching
Naruto Seishun Kyousoukyoku Naruto Seishun Kyousoukyoku

52. Maclaren Twin Techno Stroller
Im A Panty Sniffer Im A Panty Sniffer

53. Flash Hentai 3way
Adriana Dominguez Playboy Tv Adriana Dominguez Playboy Tv

54. Georgious Tits
Adult Frenuloplasty Adult Frenuloplasty

55. Seduced Ny Cougar
Im A Panty Sniffer Im A Panty Sniffer

56. Brassiere Sex Stories
Rbsinsurance Bestiality Rbsinsurance Bestiality

57. Romantic Spanking Videos
Bdsm Crucifixion Bdsm Crucifixion

58. Sheets Twin Xl 400tc
Donna Ribka Donna Ribka

59. Vanity Mcmurtry
Digimon Dcyber Digimon Dcyber

60. anime sex games
anime incest | anime drawings | anime angel | lesbian anime sex | anime furry | naruto anime | anime pics http://minks477o5sh.jed.pl/ http://opposesei2o1i.jed.pl/ http://detaila03y7yu.jed.pl/ http://revile7rosw4e.jed.pl/ http://rightsvj7e9.jed.pl/ http://seduces3j3j0.jed.pl/

61. Latin King Des Moines
Allison Munn Nude Allison Munn Nude

62. Largest Clits
Dry Moly Lube Dry Moly Lube

63. Sajin Komamura Fanfiction
Floydian Slip Floydian Slip

64. Vintage Andrea By Sadek
Marrage And Boring Sex Marrage And Boring Sex

65. Grip Korean Inuyasha
Barrick The Mermaid Barrick The Mermaid

66. Rotating Vibrators
Quadraplex Older Quadraplex Older

67. Danville Facial Plastic Surgery
Briggs Riley Travelware Briggs Riley Travelware

68. Jesse Samel
Nikki Cox Nude Nikki Cox Nude

69. Odex Private Limited
Inexpensive Front Fastening Bras Inexpensive Front Fastening Bras

70. Zaila Naked
Richmond Hill Facial Fillers Richmond Hill Facial Fillers

71. Free Naked Teens
Adult Personels Adult Personels

72. Daddy Spanked With Hairbrush
Virgin Exercise Music Muscle Virgin Exercise Music Muscle

73. Preggo Diva
Demmi Moore Porn Demmi Moore Porn

74. Epals For Sex
Dynex Webcam Dynex Webcam

75. Bbs Lm Dbk
Tantra Retreats Illinois Tantra Retreats Illinois

76. Sexy Brust
Teen Hitchikers Teen Hitchikers Nipple Puffies Nipple Puffies

77. Teen Hitchikers
Adult Incredimail Letters Adult Incredimail Letters Milf Humter Milf Humter

78. Adult Incredimail Letters
Adult Aspergers Texas Facilities Adult Aspergers Texas Facilities Treadle Swing Treadle Swing

79. Sorority Panty Raid
Besality Porn Besality Porn Laura Prepon Nude Fakes Laura Prepon Nude Fakes

80. Transumbilical Breast Augmentation Texas
Gal Gadot Gal Gadot Megapage Celeb Megapage Celeb

81. Lyrics To Hustler Musik
Starr Radwinter Starr Radwinter Lyrics To Hustler Musik Lyrics To Hustler Musik

82. Russian Dating Scams
Sexual Postions Sexual Postions Butch Ohare Butch Ohare

83. Sexy Samira
Shia Labeouf Nude Shia Labeouf Nude Risque Naughty Lingerie Risque Naughty Lingerie

84. Jankovic Cameltoe
Cankor Sores Cankor Sores Shaving Genitals Shaving Genitals

85. Mintes Bikini Page
Berkey Gay Furniture Berkey Gay Furniture Allentown Dental Implants Allentown Dental Implants

86. Tiva Free Porn
Teri Neal Cumming Georgia Teri Neal Cumming Georgia

87. slut wife stories
watching my wife | wife naked | hot video of my wife | wife getting fucked | wife swapping stories | wife in bed | angels wife lovers http://www.angelfire.com/matureadult/watching-my-wife.html http://www.angelfire.com/matureadult/wife-naked.html http://www.angelfire.com/matureadult/wifeposter-com.html http://www.angelfire.com/matureadult/wife-porn.html http://www.angelfire.com/matureadult/drunk-wife.html http://www.angelfire.com/matureadult/wife-fucking.html

88. wife flashing truckers
house wife | braless wife | gangbang slut wife stories | polaroids of my wife | pleasebangmywife | wife pussy | wife gangbang http://www.angelfire.com/matureadult/free-wifeysworld.html http://www.angelfire.com/matureadult/braless-wife.html http://www.angelfire.com/matureadult/wifes.html http://www.angelfire.com/matureadult/polaroids-of-my-wife.html http://www.angelfire.com/matureadult/pleasebangmywife.html http://www.angelfire.com/matureadult/wife-pussy.html

89. Nosler Rifle Brass
Sexy Patty Cake Sexy Patty Cake

90. Free Porn For Psp
Discrete Sex Stories Discrete Sex Stories

91. Girls Canopy Bedding Sets
Dragonball Z Porn Dragonball Z Porn

92. Alison Waite Nude
Scott Klein Gay Bondage Scott Klein Gay Bondage

93. Sharp Pain Abdomen Pregnancy
Cock Gagger Cock Gagger

94. Nubiles Camille
Densky Donna Densky Donna

95. Essex Inn Chicago
Erotic Couplings Erotic Couplings

96. Densky Donna
Free Porn For Psp Free Porn For Psp

97. Bleach English Doujins
Niece Seduce Porn Niece Seduce Porn

98. ex wife nude
drunk wife | wife masturbating | wife fucking | wife naked | exwife | mature wife | please fuck my wife http://www.angelfire.com/matureadult/drunk-wife.html http://www.angelfire.com/matureadult/wife-lover.html http://www.angelfire.com/matureadult/wife-fucking.html http://www.angelfire.com/matureadult/wife-naked.html http://www.angelfire.com/matureadult/exwife.html http://www.angelfire.com/matureadult/showmeyourwife-com.html

99. Vintage Nude Pinups
Reluctant Slut Wives Reluctant Slut Wives

100. Tstv Gals
Bikini Roit Bikini Roit Anatomically Correct Sex Dolls Anatomically Correct Sex Dolls

101. Ncl Sucks
Homemade Pump Penis Homemade Pump Penis Quickie Mop Quickie Mop

102. Lesbian Missy Elliot
Superguide Bbs Superguide Bbs Omega Seamaster Tropic Vintage Omega Seamaster Tropic Vintage

103. Rbs Insurance Tgp
Kim Kardasian Nude Kim Kardasian Nude Garcelle Crotch Shot Garcelle Crotch Shot

104. Jays Lounge Porn Review
Peeping Tom Toilet Voyeur Peeping Tom Toilet Voyeur Adult Braces Littleton Adult Braces Littleton

105. Asian Hermaphridite
Seamless Pantyhose Gallery Seamless Pantyhose Gallery Teen Haircut Gallery Teen Haircut Gallery

106. Macassar Ebony Lumber
Martinsburg Implant Dentist Martinsburg Implant Dentist Latex Doll Full Sized Latex Doll Full Sized

107. Banja Bbs
Teen Room Decorating Ideas Teen Room Decorating Ideas Sexual Harassment Fact Sheet Sexual Harassment Fact Sheet

108. Butch Bianco Watkins Glen
Amateur Webwatchers Amateur Webwatchers Cribbage Pegs Cribbage Pegs

109. Eptopic Pregnancy
Electromuscular Facial Exerciser Electromuscular Facial Exerciser Ftv Larysa Ftv Larysa

110. Jeannie Buss Nude
Breast Expansion Morphs Breast Expansion Morphs Bookworm Bitches Danielle Bookworm Bitches Danielle

111. Spank The Monkey
Robbs Unofficial Celeb Robbs Unofficial Celeb Vintage Weaver Scopes Vintage Weaver Scopes

112. Pornstar Renata Daninsky
Petter Hegre Wife Petter Hegre Wife Fursuit Gay Fursuit Gay

113. Baileysbed Porn
Eggplant Anal Stretch Eggplant Anal Stretch Joey Heatherton Oops Joey Heatherton Oops

114. Angela Devi Vids
Aneros Orgasm Video Aneros Orgasm Video Cybill Shepherd Nude Cybill Shepherd Nude

115. Skye Ione Nude Pics
Vintage Km1000 Kentucky Mandolin Vintage Km1000 Kentucky Mandolin Lauren Graham Nude Pics Lauren Graham Nude Pics

116. San Benito Dental Implants
Nancy Graces Twins Nancy Graces Twins Lube Ignition Points Felt Lube Ignition Points Felt

117. Sampson Rope
Brailzian Porn Sites Brailzian Porn Sites Thaimisc Bbs Thaimisc Bbs

118. Nude Clebs
Big Breat Lovers Big Breat Lovers Donna Hemmert Donna Hemmert

119. Free Celebraty Porn
Pender Health Promotion Model Pender Health Promotion Model Bottomless Cheerleaders Bottomless Cheerleaders

120. Amateur Webwatchers
Latrice Riley Enforced Sissy Stories Boob Cruse

121. Manhattan Chin Implants
Mother Spanks Daughter Asian Seaxy Chantillon Gratuit

122. Kyou Kara Maou Fanfiction
Franchi Model 2005 Shotgun Pants Down Rectal Thermometer Andre Kertesz Nude Photography

123. Lesbian Footslave
Leslie Mann Nude Asian Decollete Anonib Teens

124. Redhead Telluride
Rbs Insurance Fuck Sexy Planet Suzy Smuggler Bbs

125. Louise Lombard Nude
Presto Fry Daddy Mark Wahlberg Shirtless Sex Junkets

126. Orem Selfcare Model
Winnie Cooper Pantyhose Page Blondie Atomic Robbs Oops Celebs

127. Jules Asner Nude
Bleach Personality Quiz Pool Blow Up Tpy Akira Lane Bikini Riot

128. Vintage Lefty Guitars
Yvonne Strzechowski Nude Bleach The Limitation Lyrics Kushies Training Pants

129. Wanking Willy
Durham Chin Implant Felixx Bbs Boylove Naked Celebertys

130. free gay sex pictures
filipino bar girls filipino bar girls

131. joebobs teen forum
maggie gyllenhaal nude maggie gyllenhaal nude

132. free cartoon sex videos
ann coulter nude ann coulter nude

133. free sex stories xxx
tits and ass tits and ass

134. big wet asses
dogs fucking women dogs fucking women

135. adult body painting
teach my ass teach my ass

136. gallery nude girl
gay teen boys gay teen boys

137. nude teen galleries
celeb sex tapes celeb sex tapes

138. xxx 89 clips
free porn vidoes free porn vidoes

139. free porn previews
sex positions pictures sex positions pictures

140. free hardcore sex
webcam girls home alone webcam girls home alone

141. leah remini nude
college girls gone wild college girls gone wild

142. free true sex stories
girls fucking guys girls fucking guys

143. sandra bullock nude
animal sex pics animal sex pics

144. hairy mature women
gay naked men gay naked men

145. free xxx bbw movies
free pokemon porn free pokemon porn

146. naked gay men
nude movie stars nude movie stars

147. college girls nude
tiny micro bikini tiny micro bikini

148. gay male massage
adult furry art galleries adult furry art galleries

149. big tit porn
young russian girls young russian girls

150. micro bikinis model galleries
daniel radcliffe nude daniel radcliffe nude

151. free tranny sex video
lauren holly nude lauren holly nude

152. virgin sex videos
christina applegate nude christina applegate nude

153. young teen lingerie model
babes kick ass babes kick ass

154. nude young models
kim kardashian sex video kim kardashian sex video

155. nude college men
pink world porn pink world porn

156. girls loving girls
sex games online sex games online

157. jenna lewis sex tape
free adult xxx free adult xxx

158. adult baby girls diapered
adult video universe adult video universe

159. lesbian girls licking
celeb nude pics celeb nude pics

160. submitted nude pics
kiera knightly nude kiera knightly nude

161. live sex cams
free bbw vids free bbw vids

162. dolly parton nude
sims 2 nude patch sims 2 nude patch

163. gay porn free
young girls naked young girls naked

164. carrie underwood nude
dog sex stories dog sex stories

165. free bbw movies
mimi rogers nude mimi rogers nude

166. free teen nudes
xxx password hacks xxx password hacks

167. jennifer connelly nude
nude beach pics nude beach pics

168. nude male models
your amatuer porn your amatuer porn

169. girls gone wild video
mardi gras girls mardi gras girls

170. teen clothing stores
sex education for teens sex education for teens

171. adult halloween costume ideas
old men fucking old men fucking

172. caught wearing girls clothes
home made porn movies home made porn movies

173. cherry coed porn
gay male escorts gay male escorts

174. hilary duff nude
lesbian sex clips lesbian sex clips

175. lisa simpson porn
adult dvd rental adult dvd rental

176. vida guerra nude
empire adult dvd empire adult dvd

177. free hentai porn games
girls with strapons girls with strapons

178. porn star list
young teen sex young teen sex

179. monica bellucci nude
free adult thumbnails free adult thumbnails

180. viagra sex
viagra retail discount viagra retail discount

181. viagra prescription for woman
viagra pictures viagra pictures

182. viagra online store
viagra no prescription viagra no prescription

183. viagra impotence pill
viagra jokes viagra jokes

184. viagra commercial
viagracom viagracom

185. viagra aphrodisiac
viagra buy in uk online viagra buy in uk online

186. story viagra
sildenafil viagra sildenafil viagra

187. pharmacy viagra
order viagra visit your doctor online order viagra visit your doctor online

<