National stragegic plan vs. socialism PDF Print E-mail
Written by Stumo   
Wednesday, 20 January 2010

As authors Ian Fletcher, Pat Choate and many others have noted, we in the U.S. need a national industrial strategy.  The point is not big government or small government, but smart government.  The big vs. small argument is ideological and emotional, and obscures which mix of policies produces the biggest benefit.

(Similarly, the debate between free trade and fair trade may not be as helpful as thinking about Smart Trade.)

The U.S. and Britain grew not through free trade, but through strategic trade.  The EU, Asian countries and any other country that grew successfully uses strategic trade, not "free trade."  The U.S. and Britain declined after switching to free trade, by ceding their advantages to other countries.  (Indeed, third world countries often did not receive benefit).  Every tax break, price support, R&D credit and myriad other programs are subsidies, but are part of (not all of) a strategic plan.  

Oil companies are on welfare.  Unemployed are on welfare.  Aircraft manufacturers are on welfare.  Single moms are on welfare.

If we agree that a national trade and economic plan is good, how do we resist the "socialism" sloganeering?  How do we detach from the silly big vs. small government debate?

Trackback(0)
Comments (1)add
0
smart all right
written by Richard Oswald , January 21, 2010
Mike, right now our government is smart all right.
Smart about what gets them elected and keeps them there. I like the idea of smart defined a different way. But I think too many of the people we have now would eat their own babies if it kept them in office. The way we used to treat the problem when we had mama sows that did that was to send them down the road never to return.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +0
Write comment
smaller | bigger

busy
 
< Prev   Next >

In the news

March 2-4, The Coalition for a Prosperous America

Legislative Fly-In

CPA will hold its Second Annual Legislative Fly-In on March 2-4, 2010.  This is a powerful opportunity for us to work together to advance trade reform in the halls of Congress.  We need to bring the concerns of the grass roots to our legislators.

This is efficient advocacy, well worth your time.  We make all the meeting arrangements with legislators or their staff, we put together materials, we plan a message, and we pack meetings together in a concentrated period of time.  You make a bigger impact with your time using only three of the 365 days in the year.

Click here to sign up for the CPA Fly In.

CPA has a special offer--limited time only: the first 50 registrants get a free copy of Ian Fletcher's new book: Free Trade Doesn't Work.  This is a highly acclaimed book about trade policy and the needed changes therein. 

Agenda:

March 2, 2010:  2p to 6p - Group meeting for training, talking points and team assignments

March 3-4, 2010:  Hill visits

Place:  Capitol Skyline Hotel, 10 I ("Eye") Street SW, Washington, DC 20024

Once you sign up with CPA, reserve your room at the Capitol Skyline Hotel by calling 202.488.7500.  You should book for the evenings of March 2 and March 3. 

If you have questions about the events, please call Sara Haimowitz, Development Coordinator, at 413-203-1410 or email at This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it